ÆTHELMEARC COLLEGE OF HERALDS - commentary archive
Letter of Intent #132
Heraldic Dismay of Abhainn Ciach Ghlais Commenting Group

Unto the industrious heralds of Aethelmearc does Livia Valentini send last-minute greetings!

Below please find our commentary for ILOI 132.  We tend to do our ILOIs from back to front.  This time, I left my notes reflecting that.
In attendance were Master Egill the Dane, Master Gille, Master Gilles de Beauchamps, Lord Aimeric de Miravel and little old me taking notes.  Any problems with commentary are most certainly mine.
 
Livia-
***
16. Badge appears clear.
15. Name appears clear.
14. Magnus Torvaldson (05/1990, W)
We find conflict.  The two surnames are fairly close.
We suggest reblazoning the device.
 
13. lovely device! (says Livia)
11. We find it clear.  Also, we note that the default position for the harp and the lyre are two different positions, therefor they have an auto cd for said difference.  (Master Egill)
 
10. Double check the Italian name Aurella. (there is no feminine form listed) - reminder for Livia
Device appears clear of conflict.
 
9. Faelan Mer (01/2009 East)
Is this the same gentle as our submitter?

8. Device appears clear. typo- contourney   
6. Device appears clear.
5. Double check name.
  Angus mac Dougall / 12, 1989 West
  We suggest submitter stays with Angus Dubh. (Lord Jehan)
Device: Conflict with the flag of Lebanon. A possible difference would be to add a complex line of division.

4. Aledis (double check the name)
Name appears free of conflict.
Device: A possible wording change Purpure, in saltire a two-tined fork and a goblet, on a chief Or a dragon passant vert.
Device appears clear...

2. Looks good!
1. Name appears clear.
Device: Sarah of Foxhaven close, but no conflict.